Skip to main content

Tkachuk family feud sparks Panthers’ comeback

How did the Tkachuk brothers’ bench argument lead the Panthers to a comeback against Detroit?
ByDaria Mironova
Nov 12, 2026; Sunrise, Florida, USA; Florida Panthers right wing Cole Schwindt (79) moves the puck against the Detroit Red Wings during the third period at Amerant Bank Arena. Mandatory Credit: Sam Navarro-Imagn Images
Nov 12, 2026; Sunrise, Florida, USA; Florida Panthers right wing Cole Schwindt (79) moves the puck against the Detroit Red Wings during the third period at Amerant Bank Arena. Mandatory Credit: Sam Navarro-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Matthew and Brady Tkachuk finally had their first brotherly argument on the Panthers’ bench. And apparently, a little family drama helped the team in the moment.

When the Cats pulled off an impressive comeback against the Detroit Red Wings, fans saw a team that refused to give up. What they didn’t see was a family feud on the bench that may have helped turn things around.

And who better to provide the drama than Matthew and Brady Tkachuk?

He said, he said

During a recent episode of their Wingmen podcast, the brothers revealed that their first real disagreement as teammates wasn't over money, family dinner, or who was their father’s favorite. This one involved a power play, a questionable line change, and, naturally, some “professional” language.

It started when Brady left the ice early during a power play because he was exhausted.

“I changed because I was tired,” Brady explained, defending his decision to let a fresher teammate take over.

Matthew wasn’t impressed.

According to Matthew, Brady’s early departure disrupted the power-play formation and left everyone playing unfamiliar positions.

“Nobody gets off that quick by himself,” Matthew insisted.

Brady had a different interpretation. He argued that Matthew had turned over the puck and then tried to blame him for the unsuccessful power play.

Typically, Matthew disagreed.

What followed was a classic sibling argument, except this one happened on an NHL bench with teammates and coaches watching.

“I think I said something like about his lack of conditioning,” Matthew recalled.

That apparently didn’t improve Brady’s mood.

The exchange escalated until Panthers assistant coach Jamie Kompon stepped in to restore order.

“It’s all right, boys. We’re good here, boys,” Kompon told them.

The impact

Somewhere between the accusations and colorful language, the Panthers apparently found a spark.

“I think it got the boys going,” Matthew admitted. “And we rallied and got the comeback.”

Brady downplayed the confrontation, although he acknowledged that their first disagreement as teammates was probably inevitable.

And Matthew couldn’t resist one final reminder that Brady had abandoned the power play early.

When we watched Florida’s remarkable comeback against the Detroit Red Wings, we saw determination, momentum, and a team fighting its way back into the game. We had no idea that the Tkachuk brothers' dispute might have added some extra motivation, as they jokingly suggested.

Forget the inspirational speeches. Maybe the Panthers just needed two siblings arguing about a line change.

Add us as a preferred source on Google