Skip to main content

Did the Edmonton Oilers expose the Florida Panthers as pretenders instead of contenders?

The Florida Panthers' 5-2 loss to the Edmonton Oilers exposed troubling weaknesses in their goaltending, five-on-five play, and Stanley Cup aspirations.
ByRyan Gagne
Edmonton Oilers center Connor McDavid (97) scores against Florida Panthers goaltender Jacob Markstrom (25) during the first period at Amerant Bank Arena. Mandatory Credit: Sam Navarro-Imagn Images
Edmonton Oilers center Connor McDavid (97) scores against Florida Panthers goaltender Jacob Markstrom (25) during the first period at Amerant Bank Arena. Mandatory Credit: Sam Navarro-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Florida Panthers and their fans had a rude awakening on Tuesday night when they were defeated 5-2 by the Edmonton Oilers. Although the final score was somewhat deceiving, Edmonton held a 4-0 lead for an extended period before the Cats finally got on the board with less than 10 minutes remaining. Although Florida won the shots-on-goal battle and was significantly more physical, outhitting Edmonton 40-19, the Oilers exposed several glaring weaknesses in the Panthers' game.

It's been difficult for any NHL team to slow down Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, who continue to rewrite the record books. On Tuesday, McDavid collected two points, while Draisaitl finished with three, bringing their combined season total to 99. To put that into perspective, the entire Panthers roster has combined for 190 individual points, meaning Edmonton's two superstars have produced the equivalent of 52.1% of Florida's total.

However, the Oilers' offensive success goes beyond their two biggest stars, and a more in-depth look into both teams' statistics reveals some troubling trends for a Panthers club hoping to return to the Stanley Cup Final.

Panthers' five-on-five struggles are concerning

Over the past half-decade, the Panthers have built their championship identities around physicality, depth, and balanced scoring, but this year, Florida's five-on-five statistics have been quite concerning.

Through 23 games, the Panthers have scored 72 goals while surrendering 68, giving them a plus-four goal differential. However, when looking strictly at five-on-five play, the numbers tell a much different story. Florida has scored just 38 goals while allowing 44, leaving the club with a minus-six differential.

Meanwhile, Edmonton leads the NHL with 91 goals scored and has surrendered only 60. At five-on-five, the Oilers have outscored their opponents 47-36, giving them a plus-11 differential.

That's a 17-goal difference between two teams that have battled for the Stanley Cup in recent years.

Of course, the Oilers have relied heavily on McDavid and Draisaitl, but the numbers suggest they are getting the job done at even strength, too. And while Florida has received contributions from the Tkachuks, Sam Reinhart, Anton Lundell, and Seth Jones, the Panthers haven't been nearly as effective at keeping the puck out of their own net.

Meanwhile, both clubs have found considerable success on special teams. At the moment, Edmonton ranks second in the NHL with a 35.1% success rate on the power play, while Florida sits 10th at 24.2%. The Oilers have scored 24 power-play goals compared to the Panthers' 22, demonstrating how important special teams have become to both clubs.

However, Florida's inability to consistently outscore opponents at five-on-five is concerning, especially considering how much more difficult it becomes to draw penalties and take advantage of on the power play during the postseason.

Florida's goaltending is no longer championship-caliber

Perhaps the most concerning part of the Panthers’ season has been the performance of their goalies.

Through 23 games, Jacob Markström, Akira Schmid, and Cooper Black have combined for a .890 save percentage and 2.78 goals-against average. Those numbers are hardly reassuring for a team with aspirations of making another deep postseason run.

As the Cats’ No. 1 goalie, Markström has posted a .898 save percentage and 2.56 GAA. Meanwhile, Schmid has struggled with an .885 save percentage and 2.98 GAA, while Black recorded an .857 save percentage and 3.15 GAA in his lone appearance.

After years in Calgary, it’s no surprise that Markström has struggled against the Oilers in his career. Following Tuesday's defeat, he owns a 15-18-2 record against the Oilers, accompanied by a 3.02 GAA and .897 save percentage.

While goalies cannot be blamed for every defensive breakdown or bad bounce, Florida's current duo are a far cry from the championship-caliber goaltending that helped the franchise reach three consecutive Stanley Cup Finals between 2023 and 2025.

In the event the Panthers and Oilers meet again in the Stanley Cup Final, Florida's goaltending could become its biggest liability unless they get an upgrade at some point this season. With McDavid and Draisaitl capable of taking over games at any moment, Florida cannot afford to surrender four goals before finding their own offense.

Panthers continue to struggle against playoff-caliber opponents

On social media, some Panthers fans argued that Florida actually kept Edmonton in check and that the visitors only won because of two power-play goals. Others pointed out how different the game could have been if Aleksander Barkov and Brad Marchand were in the lineup.

There's some truth to those arguments, but injuries are part of the NHL, and every team deals with missing players. Good teams find ways to win despite those absences.

Last season, the Panthers struggled mightily without the stars who helped lead them to back-to-back Stanley Cup championships. This year, two key players have missed significant time, but Florida still has enough talent throughout its lineup to remain competitive.

However, perhaps the most troubling statistic is Florida's performance against teams currently occupying playoff spots.

The Panthers have defeated just one such opponent this season, the Carolina Hurricanes on Opening Night. Since then, Florida has suffered regulation losses to Minnesota, Ottawa, Boston, and Edmonton, along with an overtime defeat against Dallas.

That leaves the Panthers with a 1-4-1 record against playoff-position teams, earning just three of a possible 12 points. Meanwhile, Florida has gone 11-4-2 against everyone else.

It's one thing to beat struggling teams and accumulate points in the standings. It's another to consistently compete against the NHL's best, something the Panthers haven't demonstrated nearly enough through their first 23 games.

And while the Panthers have every reason to believe they'll improve when Barkov and Marchand return, there's no guarantee getting healthy will suddenly solve their five-on-five struggles or goaltending concerns.

Are the Panthers playing above their weight class?

There's no denying that Edmonton has its own weaknesses. The Oilers remain heavily dependent on McDavid and Draisaitl, and their dangerous power play continues to play an important part in their success. However, the numbers also reveal that Edmonton is outperforming Florida at five-on-five, an area where the Panthers have traditionally excelled.

Through 23 games of the 2026-27 season, those characteristics haven't consistently appeared together.

Florida's 12-8-3 record isn't disastrous, but it also doesn't reflect the dominance fans have grown accustomed to seeing. With a negative five-on-five goal differential, inconsistent goaltending, and just one victory against teams currently occupying playoff spots, there's little evidence that these Panthers belong among the NHL's elite.

There's still plenty of hockey remaining, giving the Panthers plenty of time to address their problems. But unless their goaltending improves and they begin beating playoff-caliber opponents, another trip to the Stanley Cup Final could be nothing more than wishful thinking.

For now, the Panthers may look like contenders on paper, but their results against the NHL's best suggest otherwise.

Add us as a preferred source on Google